
Nanocarbon HPP harder and smoother than PEEK and BioHPP in the laboratory
Across 42 samples subjected to thermocyclic ageing and 28 days in a staining medium, all three high-performance polymers differed statistically significantly in colour stability, roughness and hardness, and nanocarbon HPP performed best.
Three polymers, the same ageing, a different outcome
High-performance polymers are increasingly replacing metal alloys in prosthetic work — because of esthetics, weight, the absence of corrosion and price. Which of them best withstands everyday loading is the question an in vitro study published in BMC Oral Health set out to answer.
Forty-two cylindrical samples were produced by CAD/CAM technology and divided into three groups of 14: nanocarbon high-performance polymer, BioHPP and PEEK. All samples were subjected to thermocyclic ageing. Colour stability was measured spectrophotometrically after 28 days of immersion in a staining medium, surface roughness with a profilometer, and hardness by the Vickers method.
Statistically significant differences in all three measured properties were found between all three groups. Nanocarbon HPP combined low surface roughness with high hardness, which the authors describe as the mechanically most convincing of the options tested. They direct their conclusion towards extensive work — full-arch prostheses and implant-supported restorations, where the combination of low roughness and high hardness promises longer durability and less plaque accumulation.
Limitations
This is an in vitro study with 14 samples per group, without simulation of chewing, without saliva and without a single patient, so the results do not translate directly into clinical durability. The abstract states neither the specific measured values nor the funding source, and nanocarbon HPP does not yet have the clinical documentation that PEEK and BioHPP have.
For your practice
- For a patient seeking extensive metal-free work, nanocarbon HPP is an option worth discussing with the technician, but without promises of proven longevity.
- When choosing between PEEK and BioHPP, ask the manufacturer for roughness data after polishing — it directly affects plaque accumulation.
- Do not relay test-tube results to the patient as evidence of durability; clinical comparisons of these materials are still lacking.